What University Professionals May Overlook About Retirement Planning Video from Savant Wealth Management
Preparing for retirement as a university professional can be both exciting and complex. While there is much to look forward to as you approach this important milestone, overlooking key planning considerations may affect your long-term financial goals. This educational webinar will explore retirement planning topics that university professionals may want to evaluate as they prepare for the years ahead.
Transcript
Speaker 1:
Download our complimentary guidebooks, checklists, and other useful financial resources at savantwealth.com/guides.
James Haygood:
Thank you for attending today’s webinar, which is designed specifically for university faculty and administrators. We’re going to spend about the next half hour reviewing four case studies that illustrate financial planning strategies many university employees miss. I can see we have quite a few people on the live presentation today, so thank you to everyone who’s joining us. I also want to let those joining us know that if you have a question that you’d like to ask, you can submit at any time during the discussion today by using the Q&A box, and we will respond either at the end of the webinar, or if we don’t get to your question, we’ll reach out to you directly. And we also have an offer for our listeners at the end of the presentation today for a complimentary financial review, so make sure that you listen for the details of that.
I thought a little background on our team before we get started would be helpful. At Savant, we are a comprehensive fee-only fiduciary, and we’re focused on helping our clients achieve their ideal financial futures. We work with clients across the nation, and we have a vast team of professionals that help our advisory team serve our clients in a holistic manner. I’m joined today by my colleague, John Clarke.
John Clarke:
Good afternoon, James.
James Haygood:
Good afternoon, John. John and I are both certified financial planners and member owners here at Savant. John has been advising university faculty and administrators across the country for about the past 8 years, and I have been for the past 16 years. And our team has completed thousands of financial assessments during that time. We do spend a lot of time with faculty, administrators, and their families when they’re first introduced to our team, getting to understand their goals, what gaps might exist from a planning perspective. John, why don’t you share with our listeners what we’re going to be covering today during our webinar?
John Clarke:
Of course. This is something you and I have been talking about doing for quite some time. Ultimately, after having the opportunity to work with so many different university faculty and administrators and helping them take the first step in building a comprehensive plan, we’ve both seen some pretty common patterns of strategies that many university employees miss when thinking about their finances. So this should be fun. We’ll keep it conversational. We’ll walk through four case studies based on situations we see regularly with faculty and administrators, so you get a sense of what you may not be thinking about that you should be. The most helpful thing we can do today is share these often missed planning strategies that might reveal opportunities in each of your own personal plans. So I think let’s just set the stage for our first case study day, James. Let’s talk about a professor who, through no fault or intention of their own, somehow ends up with four, five, six, sometimes seven, more retirement accounts.
We run into this scenario very often, especially with mid-career faculty who take a promotion or a new position at a different institution than the one that they started at. We’re also seeing it more with faculty who have stayed at one institution throughout their entire career, but many universities have completely revamped their retirement plans or gone through a vendor change over the last decade. James, what are some of the challenges and opportunities, if any, we run into in a situation like this?
James Haygood:
Yeah, this is something that we see pretty much almost every day when meeting with faculty and it can cause headaches as well as missed opportunities. So let’s start with the default option, which is what most of you have probably chosen if you’re in this situation because doing nothing is the easiest solution. So when you start using a new plan, the old plan often just sits in the background getting little attention and it’s kind of out of sight, out of mind, and you might check the balance in that account once a year or so, and usually it’s been growing and you might think, “Why fix something that isn’t broken?” And the problem with that is that these old accounts may no longer match your goals, your risk tolerance, your overall allocation strategy. And when several accounts are invested independently, it gets kind of hard to know whether your total portfolio is actually working together or not.
So the other option that we see some of your colleagues take is to consolidate all of their old inactive accounts by rolling them into one IRA. And on the service, this is a very practical solution, but it can also lead to missed opportunities as well.
John Clarke:
Yeah, James, why don’t you talk about that a little bit further? What are some specific concerns with consolidating everything into an IRA?
James Haygood:
Yeah, that’s a great question. So with IRA consolidation, it can be a good thing, but you want to be sure that where and how you consolidate is in your best interest. Sometimes we see professors consolidate into an IRA with an advisor that doesn’t understand university retirement plans, so they are only getting help with a portion of their portfolio. And IRAs can also carry higher fees and expenses than what we saw in those old plans. So that’s why the details of consolidation really matter.
John Clarke:
So if you’re ignoring your old accounts and that’s not the best solution, you have concerns about simply consolidating everything into one IRA, what’s a practical solution that we found for professors?
James Haygood:
Yeah, we call it the unified portfolio approach, and it starts well before we think about specific investments. It actually starts with understanding your goals and overall planning objectives. And once we understand what your career path looks like, when you want to retire, what’s important to you with your family, things like travel, your living situation, healthcare, and any other meaningful goals that you have, we want to have that context so that we can build a roadmap for what to do with all of these accounts. And from there, we start at a high level with a target asset allocation that matches not only your risk tolerance, but also your liquidity needs based on those planning goals. Next, we’re going to take a look at the unique rules and advantages of each of the plans that you have and each plan’s custodian. For example, TIAA often has very different fund lineup and options than what we might find in Fidelity.
So we want to play to the strengths of each of those custodians. And TIAA also offers a fund called TI Traditional, which is a unique fund in terms of its rules, and those rules vary by plan, including restrictions on how and when you can withdraw or transfer that money. So we need to understand those rules and plan around them so that we can make the most of it as a fixed income component in your portfolio, for example. And then we’ll use reporting software to bring all of your accounts into one view, and that way we can see your total allocation and performance in one place. So this approach also lets us focus on your current plan where you’re working, and that way we can see contributions and how they’re actively going in and make strategic decisions to get the most out of your benefits based on everything else that you’ve accumulated over your career.
John Clarke:
Yeah, we definitely see how that approach makes sense, James, to simplify things. Is there anything a professor should keep in mind about an advisor they work with if they want to implement some of these ideas you’re talking about?
James Haygood:
Yeah, there’s a few things to keep in mind. First, you want to look for an independent advisor because this approach requires working across multiple custodial platforms. So if an advisor you’re talking to is employed directly by one of the custodians, they’re going to be limited in how they can help you with assets that are held elsewhere. Second, you want to avoid relationships where the advisor is selling specific products or where the fee structure is unclear. And finally, you really want to find somebody who truly understands the nuances of university retirement plans.
John Clarke:
Thanks, James. I think that’s helpful. Let’s move on to our next scenario, which has been a theme for retiring faculty for as long as we’ve been doing this. Universities offer generous retirement contributions and many faculty add voluntary savings throughout their careers. So it’s very common to approach retirement with large balances and just pre-tax retirement plans. Many professors also work up to or even past required minimum distribution age, which we’ll talk about a little bit further in this webinar today. So you can find yourself facing a high tax bill in retirement.
James Haygood:
Yeah, you’re exactly right. And tax rates have remained at historic lows really since the Tax Cut and Jobs Act was passed in 2017. But as we see in the news all the time with the national debt rising quickly and continued pressure on some of the entitlement programs like social security, future tax rate increases are seeming more and more likely. We speak with many of your colleagues who are going to find themselves scrambling in the last couple years of work leading up to retirement to try to find ways to reduce their income tax liability once they do stop working. And the opportunity that I want to focus on in this scenario that we’re talking through is using Roth accounts going forward because this is a question that we’re getting very frequently right now.
John Clarke:
Yeah. And for all of those listening today, James, can you just briefly explain what a Roth account is?
James Haygood:
Yeah, so traditional retirement accounts are tax deferred, meaning you pay income tax not when the money goes in, but when the money is distributed in the future at whatever your tax rate is at that time. And a Roth account is basically the opposite. So the money is taxed upfront on the way in, and then it grows tax-free and qualified withdrawals are tax-free as well as long as you follow a couple of the rules around them.
John Clarke:
So if you can lock in a low tax rate when they make the contribution, they don’t have to worry about paying higher taxes in the future when they actually start spending the assets.
James Haygood:
Exactly. And there’s also an added benefit, which is Roth assets that you leave to your heirs keep their tax-free treatment. And most non-spouse heirs, like children for example, can leave the money in the inherited account for up to 10 years continuing to grow tax-free as a Roth. So that makes Roth a very powerful asset transfer tool as well. There’s a few ways to get money into a Roth account so we can talk through those. The first is making annual Roth IRA contributions, if you have earned income, but these do have income limits and faculty commonly exceed those limits, so that might not be an option for everyone. The second is what’s called a backdoor Roth, and that’s where you make a non-deductible IRA contribution and then you immediately convert it to a Roth. And that’s a strategy that sometimes higher earners that are over those Roth IRA limits will do.
But this can get complicated, especially if you already have pre-tax IRA balances because those balances can cause part of that conversion to be taxable. And the third is what’s called a Roth conversion. So that’s where we take money that’s already in a traditional tax-deferred IRA or other tax-deferred retirement account and convert it to a Roth by paying the income tax on the amount that’s converted. And conversions can be attractive because you get to control how much you convert in a given year and there’s no contribution limits or income restrictions to worry about with that strategy. And conversions are particularly attractive for someone who’s going to retire before RMD age, which is either 73 or 75 for most of us that aren’t retired yet, and their income is lower than what it is while you’re still working. Or if your income is lower when you retire, then it will be once required minimum distributions do kick in the future.
John Clarke:
Got it. Yeah. And we’ve seen many universities have started offering a Roth option on their menu within the 403(b) plans that money type’s now available. So how does that fit into the equation?
James Haygood:
Yeah, that’s a really good point because I think this is actually the most overlooked Roth option for university professors. And at almost all university retirement plans now, they let you choose whether your voluntary contributions go in as traditional pre-tax or as Roth. And this is very attractive because as an employer sponsored plan, there’s no income restrictions like there are with Roth IRAs. And depending on your age, you can contribute a little over $30,000 per year as Roth to a 403(b). And some universities are also offering 457(b) plans that also allow Roth contributions, which means at some institutions you may be able to save over $50,000 per year in a Roth while you’re still working.
John Clarke:
That’s great. So James, before we move on, can you just wrap up some key takeaways for those listening on Roth for everyone on the call today?
James Haygood:
Yeah. So if you’re concerned about taxes in retirement, Roth is going to give you a way to basically pay taxes now at rates that you know in exchange for tax-free growth and tax-free qualified withdrawals later on. It also gives you more control over your future tax bill because money that’s in a Roth account isn’t subject to required minimum distributions or taxed when you take it out, and it can pass to your heirs with the same tax-free treatment that you would get. There are several ways to build up Roth assets like we talked about. So Roth IRA contributions, if your income allows for that, backdoor Roth contributions, Roth conversions. And then the one that I would encourage everyone listening to check out would be the Roth option in your university 403(b) or the 457(b) plan. And the right mix is going to really depend on your income today and also what your expected income in retirement is going to look like and your overall planning goals.
And it’s rarely all or nothing. Many of our faculty clients end up with balances in both pre-tax and Roth dollars, and that’s going to give you and them flexibility to manage your taxes year by year in retirement. The first step is going to be to look at your own situation so you can decide how much Roth makes sense for you and the best way to get there. John, why don’t we shift gears and look at the third situation now for retirement? And we spend a lot of time talking about whether someone has saved enough for retirement, but what happens when the opposite’s true? What if somebody who’s been working and saving for a long time has actually accumulated more retirement assets than they’re going to realistically need for themself?
John Clarke:
Yeah, and funny enough, we actually see this quite a bit with professors who have worked long careers, saved consistently, and maybe worked longer than they originally expected. I often joke with professors that they have sort of a rolling five-year retirement date. Their careers may span four decades at the same institution. The goal isn’t necessarily to retire as quickly as possible, but eventually they reach a point where they recognize, “Okay, retirement is an eventuality and we all face it.” So at that point, the question often changes from, “Can I afford to retire to how do I manage everything I’ve accumulated in the most thoughtful way?” They may have significant assets in their university retirement plans, a healthy brokerage account outside of those plans and a lifestyle that doesn’t really require to immediately start pulling money from retirement accounts. So the core concern isn’t whether they have enough, it’s becoming more about how to efficiently pull those assets over the rest of their life. And then ultimately, when they do pull those assets, how do we do that in an efficient fashion?
James Haygood:
Well, that sounds like a good problem to have to me.
John Clarke:
Yeah, it absolutely is, but it can create a different set of planning issues. So if most of that retirement money is pre-tax, eventually required minimum distributions enter the picture. And if somebody is already concerned about paying too much in taxes, as we talked about early, simply allowing those accounts to continue growing without thinking about the eventual tax consequences isn’t necessarily the best choice.
James Haygood:
So if you’re working with somebody who’s in this situation, where do you usually start with them?
John Clarke:
Yeah, I think we almost have to work backwards and start with their goals. So if a professor doesn’t need the retirement accounts to fund their lifestyle, what is the money ultimately for? I mean, I think that’s the biggest question. Is it likely to be spent later in retirement? Is there a desire to leave money to children or to family? Is charitable giving important, maybe even giving back to the university where they spent a lot of their career? Oftentimes, it’s sometimes a combination of those three rights, not just one. So once we understand the ultimate purpose of the money, we can make much better decisions about what to do with it today.
James Haygood:
What would be an example based on one of those goals that you mentioned?
John Clarke:
Yeah, so let’s just start with a professor that’s charitably inclined. We may want to think strategically about which assets ultimately get used for charitable giving and which assets we’d rather preserve for family. Or if there’s a period after they leave the university when their taxable income declines, but before required minimum distributions become significant, we may evaluate whether partial Roth conversions make sense during the window, which James discussed earlier in our conversation. Then we also need to incorporate taxable assets if those exist. So that gives us another source of liquidity, so we don’t just have to automatically start pulling money from retirement accounts simply because someone has in fact retired.
James Haygood:
Yeah, I think that’s an important distinction. Retirement doesn’t necessarily mean that you’re just taking money out of your retirement accounts the next day once you do retire.
John Clarke:
Yeah, exactly. And that’s also where the investment strategy becomes really important. If you have enough outside assets to support your lifestyle and you don’t anticipate spending a large portion of the retirement accounts for many years, should every account really be invested as though it needs to fund next year’s expenses, right? Probably not. I think most of our listeners would agree with that. So some of that money may have a much longer time horizon, which is what I was getting at before, because ultimately it’s being invested for the next generation or for charitable goals. We want the investment strategy, tax strategy, charitable strategy, and estate plan all working together holistically.
James Haygood:
So what if, for example, the professors retiring later, required minimum distributions have already begun and they still have significant pre-tax retirement assets? How does that change the scenario?
John Clarke:
Yeah, the planning definitely changes in that scenario. So if meeting their lifestyle needs is relatively easy still, we’re spending less time asking, “Where’s the next year’s income coming from,” and more time just asking, “How do we manage the tax consequences of these assets over the rest of their life?” So if we continue with the charitable giving example that we started with, charitable giving, if someone is in fact charitably inclined, we want to give to charity if it’s in fact important to us. But qualified charitable distributions or QCDs for short, from an eligible IRA can potentially satisfy part or all of the amount that’s otherwise required to distribute while directing those dollars to the charity and then in turn alleviating the income tax burden associated. So for a university professor though, a large portion of the retirement assets, as I mentioned IRA account, it may still be staying in a 403(b), so there is some planning and account coordination operationally required before that strategy is available.
And then we look at the taxable account too. If someone has held investments for a long time in a brokerage account, they may have appreciated positions, appreciated stocks. Rather than selling those investments, realizing the gain and then writing a check to the charity, gifting appreciated securities may be a much more tax-efficient solution. And then depending on their goals long-term, a donor-advised fund to go along with that may also be worth considering to smooth out the gifting. So the important part of this, that we don’t just look at any strategy in isolation, which account should fund lifestyle, which assets are best suited for charity, which assets do we want to preserve for family, and what does each decision do to the tax picture 5, 10, or even 20 years from now? That’s really where the planning opportunities present themselves.
James Haygood:
Super helpful, John, so thanks for walking us through those couple of scenarios, but why don’t we shift over to our last case and this one I think that our audience will relate to because retirement for a professor, as you’ve already kind of alluded to, often doesn’t look like traditional retirement. There’s not always a date where somebody works full-time and retire on Friday, and then on Monday they’re just completely done working.
John Clarke:
Yeah, definitely. And that’s one of the biggest things we try to understand when we start working with someone approaching retirement. When somebody tells us, “I’d like to retire in three years,” one of my first questions is usually, “Well, what does retirement actually mean to you?” Because it can mean something completely different depending on the person.
James Haygood:
Maybe we could use a physician at a university as an example for that.
John Clarke:
Yeah, I think that’s a great one to start with. You could have a physician connected to the university with several different components to their income. Maybe they’re receiving university compensation, separate clinical income, and then potentially some form of additional executive compensation rather than stopping everything at once. They may want to gradually reduce the clinical side of their work. That’s a pretty common thing that we’ve both seen. So someone might say they’re retiring, but financially, that’s not actually what’s happening. Their income is stepping down over a period of time.
James Haygood:
And that has to make the retirement income planning part of our work a little bit more complicated.
John Clarke:
It does, but it can also create some opportunities instead of simply asking, “How much do we need to withdraw from the portfolio when we retire?” We’re mapping out the different income sources and figuring out when the portfolio is actually needed to start supplementing them. That’s where the tax planning becomes important too, as earned income declines. There may be different planning opportunities along the way. I think the important thing is that we model those stages rather than assuming income goes from 100% to zero overnight.
James Haygood:
John, this scenario you’re talking about isn’t just limited to physicians. We see this with all different types of faculty, right?
John Clarke:
Oh, certainly. Yeah, not at all. Yeah. So another common example is I would say a faculty member who wants to leave the university but actually continue consulting. Sometimes consulting can be with professors where consulting is not just a small side project, it can be a meaningful source of income that is sometimes even larger than their university incomes, and then they fully intend to continue doing that after leaving the universities. That’s just another example of that profile.
James Haygood:
So would you consider someone like that actually retired or not?
John Clarke:
Well, that’s the interesting part. From the university’s perspective, we might be getting to emeritus status maybe. From a financial planning perspective, I’m not sure if the label really matters. What matters is understanding where the cash flow is going to look like and modeling that out and seeing different scenarios and different solutions because we’ve seen… And oftentimes, people don’t know. They make a decision in that moment where you say, “I’m done working.” So when we’re looking 5, 10 years out, we want to look at if the consulting income’s going to continue, if the clinical work is going to continue. If we remove that entirely, what does that look like? So those are the types of scenarios we run. So maybe the university paycheck goes away, but the consulting continues. Now we need to understand how much income that’s likely to generate, how long they want to continue working, whether that creates any ongoing retirement plan contribution opportunities and when they actually need to start drawing from their investment portfolio.
James Haygood:
So someone could stop working at the university, but still actually be accumulating retirement assets rather than drawing down on them?
John Clarke:
Yeah, absolutely. And that’s exactly what we’re talking about. I don’t love assuming there’s one retirement date that’s driving the entire plan. For some people, and for a lot of the individuals that we’ve had the chance to work with, that there’s really a retirement transition. Maybe you go from full-time university work to consulting or reduced clinical work and eventually to a point where work becomes optional. The financial plan should be built around these different stages and then tie back to your goals so we can really get a sense of what you want to do. That’s most important to us.
James Haygood:
And that’s going to bleed into other areas and impact things like social security?
John Clarke:
Yeah, and taxes too. It can affect just about everything, and that’s why we want to build a plan around the person’s actual life rather than have arbitrary retirement age attached. We want to know when each income source changes, when portfolio withdrawals are really needed, and where there may be opportunities to make social security investment or retirement plan decisions along the way. Ultimately, the question isn’t just, “When are you retiring?” It’s, “What do you want for work, life to look like in the next 5 or 10 years and how should the financial plan support that transition?”
James Haygood:
Good stuff, John. And as we wrap this up, I think probably the common theme across all the examples that we’ve talked about is that there really isn’t one retirement formula that works for every professor.
John Clarke:
Yeah, exactly. Two people can be working at the same university, be the same age, have similar account balances, but the right strategy could be completely different based on their income, taxes, family, charitable goals, investment mix, and what they actually want retirement to look like. And that’s why the best place to start is by understanding where you are today and then identifying, I think, what’s going to actually matter going forward. So for our listeners who are getting closer to retirement and just wondering, people go through an exploration phase we find, wondering how all these pieces fit together, we’d be happy to prepare a complimentary financial analysis, that gives us an opportunity to take a closer look at your retirement income picture, investments, taxes, estate considerations in a holistic manner, and then identify some of the planning opportunities or potential gaps that may be worth addressing moving forward.
James Haygood:
So someone doesn’t necessarily need to have all those answers ready for themself before starting that conversation?
John Clarke:
No, not at all. And in fact, that’s the whole point of conducting the analysis. You bring us the questions and the financial picture and we’ll help you understand what we think deserves the most attention. If we’re within a few years of retirement or simply trying to figure out what the next stage should look like, we’d be happy to have that conversation.
James Haygood:
Great. And for anyone that’s listening, if you’re interested in the complimentary analysis, you can click the link below and complete a registration form… Excuse me. Or you can send us a chat letting us know that you’re interested and we will reach out to you about next steps. John, do you mind taking a moment and walking us through what the process looks like for the analysis?
John Clarke:
Yeah, absolutely. I’d be happy to share some of the details involved in the analysis process. Typically, our whole initial effort is to assist families in getting more organized. Some people have a really good head start, others are just having a hard time locating everything that makes up their financial life. So that requires a pretty detailed information gathering process. So we look to receive basically the building blocks of your financial life, which includes items like your investment statements, tax returns, if you have estate documents, financial planning goals, any other items so we can get a clear picture of what’s most important to you, and then we can identify some of the gaps that may also exist. The good news is we make this process very seamless, we make it secure, and it’s collaborative, so we want to make sure that it works with your schedule. We recognize that a lot of the people that we work with are traveling quite a bit, they’re quite busy, so we want to make sure, especially as we near the holiday season, that it works with your schedule.
So we work on basically putting together a timeline, and then typically we establish not one but two analysis meetings. So one that serves as basically further discovery, so we understand your picture and your goals completely. And then the second, which is where we provide final recommendations on what we think you should do moving forward before you implement a holistic plan for your family. So we take great care in that process, so we ask that any families that explore that initial analysis also have a sincere interest in exploring a partnership with Savant. So hopefully those details are helpful. James, I think it might be appropriate if we just moved on to some of the questions that were submitted during our discussion today.
James Haygood:
Yeah. Yeah, let’s go for it.
John Clarke:
Yeah, let’s go for it. Okay. I’ll pull the first one. I think this one’s for you, James, on your first section. Says, “How do I know if I’m maximizing my retirement plan contributions?
James Haygood:
Yeah, that’s a good question. It really depends at the institution you’re working at and also depends a lot on your age. So there are some kind of blanket rules. Most universities, if you have a pension plan, then sometimes part of the employer match that would normally go to a 403(b) plan, for example, might be going to the pension. So that’s something to understand first that can impact how much you have available to save towards retirement. Other universities that don’t have the pension plan, typically you can save around 23, $24,000. They move the field goal post just a little bit each year based on inflation up until age 50. And then if you’re over age 50, you’re allowed to do supplemental contributions on top of that. So you can get up a little bit over $30,000. And then if you’re between ages 60 and 63, then there’s a super catch-up contribution for a short period of time where you can do another couple thousand dollars towards that plan.
And then as I mentioned before, some universities offer 457(b) plans, which are… It’s a different IRS code. So if you fill up that bucket on the 403(b) side, there’s another bucket you can use and those can have, depending on the university, similar limits on that. So we want to look at the plan specifically. And then one other thing I always like to remind our clients because consulting is very common with academics is that if you have consulting income and you’re an independent contractor, there’s usually a good opportunity to save some of that or defer some of that independent contracting income that you get towards an additional retirement plan as well. So across the board, there’s a lot of money that you can be saving. And again, you want to think about is that going in pre-tax to reduce your current taxable income and we defer that into the future, pay tax later, or is that a good opportunity to do some Roth contributions and lock in tax rates today?
So if you don’t know how to go through all those different moving pieces, it is complicated, so don’t feel bad. It’s hard to know right away if you’re at those limits or not, but that’s something we’d be really happy to help you look at. If you have questions, just reach out on that.
John Clarke:
Yeah, and typically it even starts just by looking at the pay stub, right, James? You can look at the pay stub for the retirement plan contributions, pair that with university benefit plans and take a look to make sure we’re maximizing the options. But as you mentioned, as you get older, depending on the plans, there’s typically more money that you can tax defer, tax shelter.
James Haygood:
Yeah, very generous. The next one I’ll throw your way, John, this actually says, “John mentioned QCDs,” which is the qualified charitable distributions, just to clarify that, “Are not allowed from 403(b) plans. How can I do this if most of my assets are in a university account?”
John Clarke:
Yeah, and with qualified charitable distribution, something I want to be clear, it’s tied to required minimum distribution, so it’s actually tied to the original required minimum distribution age of 70 and a half. So if we’re looking at proceeding with that charitable gifting, we first have to make sure that we’re over that hurdle. So I would say that’s the first thing that might not be the best gifting strategy if you’re below that hurdle. Then the second thing that I was mentioning is just that operationally, it can’t be pulled from a 403(b) account, at least not right now. There’s some talk in the future that maybe they would allow for this, but for the time being, there would have to be some money in an IRA account. So essentially you would have to satisfy that required minimum distribution as a qualified charitable distribution from an IRA account. So there’s some technical aspects to that. All right. And then next one I think is for you, James. It’s asking about… You talked a lot about Roth conversion, so how do I know if a Roth conversion makes sense is basically the question.
James Haygood:
Yeah, it gets complicated quickly. The general idea is if you think the tax rate you’re in today or the tax rate you’re going to be in a year from now or a couple years from now is likely to be the same or lower than what your tax rate’s going to be in the future, then Roth conversions or Roth contributions are usually a good idea. That’s kind of a starting point. It does get a little bit more complicated though, if there are… For example, we talked about leaving Roth assets to other individuals. So if you’re not likely to spend all of your income and the assets you leave behind, if your children are high earners or have a high tax bracket, it might make sense for you to pay the tax on it at your rates and lock it into a Roth and leave them Roth assets.
If there’s other events down the road where you might be purchasing a home or you might need large amounts of income in a specific year to go on a vacation that you’ve always planned or purchase a cabin or something like that. Instead of taking large distributions out of an IRA account down the road and really pushing your tax bracket up in a given year, it can make sense to do some Roth conversions either in one year or spread it out and lock in lower rates for that future large contribution that you’re planning. So there’s a lot of moving pieces to it. It’s hard to know exactly the dollar amount that’s right for each person, but the more we model out, talk through your scenario and understand what your goals are, it’s easy to paint a picture, what are some good targets for that?
John Clarke:
Yeah. As everybody can tell that’s listening, James can talk about the Roth conversions all day. All right, let’s just take one more here.
James Haygood:
Yeah, I’ll let you do the last one and then we’ll wrap it up. So as you talked about simplifying the different accounts that you have, I have worked at three universities. How does this actually work in practice? I think maybe they’re asking John to share a sample of how have you done this with university [inaudible 00:36:31]-
John Clarke:
Yeah. I think you covered this section, but I’ll just touch on it a little bit. So typically there’s a lot that goes into what we would consider the consolidation process to get to that unified portfolio view that James was talking about. So in practice, there are a lot of things to consider. Are there any state benefits that are tied to the university accounts that you currently have? Are there certain reasons we want to keep assets at certain custodians? What is the investment menu long term? Are you retired? So all of that goes into the decision. And then we typically will work in conjunction with our investment research team to develop a unified portfolio plan and then work with our operations team to basically develop what we consider consolidation of custodians plans. So if you have lots of different accounts… Like James was articulating earlier, you have 15 different accounts, what is practical? How do we actually go about paring that down?
And then at the end of the day, it’s your money, right? We’re going to have a conversation around what consolidation process we think makes the most sense for you before we implement anything. So there’s typically… For somebody that ends up partnering with us, there’s typically a whole meeting during the onboarding process where you basically make decisions around that. So I think… Like I said, that probably addresses that question in the most straightforward way without getting into too many specifics. James, do you want to wrap us up here?
James Haygood:
Yeah. Again, if you send us a question that we didn’t get to today, we’ll reach out to you privately. There will be a follow-up email that will go out as well, so you’ll have an opportunity to check out the recording of this, if you miss something, you want to share it with one of your colleagues. And as John and I mentioned, if you have questions or need help getting started on any of this, reach out. We’d love to connect with you and try to help get you pointed in the right direction. So thanks everyone for joining us, and we’ll hope to see you at the next one. Take care.
John Clarke:
Thank you.
Speaker 1:
Download our complimentary guidebooks, checklists, and other useful financial resources at savantwealth.com/guides.